Journal/Mattress toppers

Mattress Topper vs Mattress Protector vs Underlay: Which Do You Need?

A protector, a topper and an underlay do three different jobs, and most beds need two of them. What each one does, which combination suits your bed, and which goes on first.

By Ethan Larcombe| | 9 min read

New Zealand Wool Mattress Topper folded on a sheet of felted wool, showing its thin quilted layers and elastic corner strap

A mattress protector keeps your mattress clean. A mattress topper changes the bed you lie on, either how it feels or how it handles heat and moisture. An underlay, in New Zealand and Australian shops, is a fleece wool layer sold for winter warmth. They do three different jobs, and most beds need two of them. If your mattress is new, the protector is usually not optional: CHOICE notes that almost all mattress brands require one during the free trial.

New to toppers? Start with our complete guide to mattress toppers.

The short answer

  • Protector: a thin fabric layer, often waterproof, that stops sweat, spills and stains reaching the mattress. It does nothing for how the bed feels.
  • Topper: a removable layer that changes the bed. Thick foam or latex makes it softer. A thin wool layer keeps the feel and changes how the surface handles heat and moisture.
  • Underlay: a fleecy wool layer, usually reversible, bought to make a bed warmer in winter.
  • Order: mattress first, fitted sheet last. Whether the protector goes above or below the topper depends on what the topper is made of, which we cover below.

What does a mattress protector do?

One job: keep the mattress clean. Every night a bed takes on sweat, skin cells and body oils, and every so often a spilt drink or a child's accident. A protector catches all of it before it reaches the mattress, and it goes in the washing machine. The mattress does not.

That matters more than it sounds, because a stained mattress is a warranty problem. CHOICE puts it bluntly: mattress warranties do not cover stains, and stains are often used as a reason to refuse claims for unrelated faults. Tom's Guide reports the same pattern overseas, with warranties voided by stains even when the stain has nothing to do with the claim. It is also why almost all brands that offer a sleep trial require a protector during it. Consumer NZ's advice is the simplest version: use a mattress protector to keep it clean.

Protectors come in two kinds. Plain quilted or fabric protectors catch everyday sweat and dust but let spills through. Waterproof protectors add a membrane, usually polyurethane, that stops liquid completely. That membrane is the whole point, and also the trade-off. A layer that stops liquid also slows moisture vapour, so a waterproof protector can make a bed that already runs warm feel warmer and clammier. If you need one, there is a way around that, and it comes down to what goes on top of it.

What does a mattress topper do?

A topper is a removable layer that sits on the mattress, under the fitted sheet, and it does one of two jobs. CHOICE describes the classic version as an extra layer about 2 to 10cm high whose main purpose is making a mattress feel firmer or softer. That is the thick topper: memory foam, latex, feather or lofty fibre, bought because the mattress is not quite right.

The second job is changing how the bed behaves rather than how it feels. A thin, dense natural layer sits between you and the mattress and handles the moisture you give off at night, which is what makes a bed feel hot and clammy. Wool can absorb up to a third of its own weight in moisture without feeling damp, so a wool layer keeps the surface drier and regulates the temperature of the bed without touching its firmness. Our New Zealand Wool Mattress Topper is that kind: a thin wool layer, less than a centimetre thick, that keeps the feel of your mattress. If you are deciding between the two jobs, our post on thick vs low-profile toppers walks through it.

What a topper is not is a protector. CHOICE makes the same point. A thick foam topper cannot be washed, and no topper is waterproof unless it says so, which wool and foam toppers generally do not.

What is an underlay?

In New Zealand and Australia, "underlay" usually means a wool layer with a deep fleecy pile on one side and cotton on the other, often reversible, held on with an elastic skirt. They tend to be thicker and heavier than a wool topper, and they are sold mainly on warmth: a cosy layer to lie on through winter, often used alongside an electric blanket. Some shops use "underlay", "topper", "protector" and "mattress pad" almost interchangeably, which is why so many people search for the difference.

The practical difference is purpose. An underlay adds warmth and a bit of softness. A thin quilted wool topper adds very little warmth and no softness, and its job is keeping the surface dry. If your bedroom is cold and you want the bed warmer, an underlay or a warmer duvet is the answer. If your bed runs warm and clammy, a deep fleece underlay is the wrong tool and a thin wool layer is the right one.

Which layers does your bed need?

Most beds need a protector, and then one of the other two depending on the problem you are solving. Here is how it usually works out.

Your bed Protector Topper Underlay
New mattress, still on its trial or warranty Yes, usually required Optional, a thin one keeps the feel you chose Not needed
Foam mattress that sleeps hot Optional, under the topper Yes, a thin wool layer No, it adds warmth
Older spring mattress that feels fine Yes, to keep it clean Optional, for the surface Optional, in a cold room
Mattress that feels too firm Yes Yes, a thicker foam or latex one No, it will not soften it much
Cold bedroom in winter Yes Optional Yes, or a warmer wool duvet
Child's single or bunk Yes, waterproof for accidents Optional, washable is best Not needed
Campervan, motorhome or boat Optional Yes, a thin one that saves clearance Rarely, space is tight

The one combination that rarely makes sense is a topper and an underlay together. Both sit in the same place, and stacking them changes the feel of the bed and makes fitted sheets harder to get on.

Which goes on first, the protector or the topper?

Mattress first and fitted sheet last, always. The question is the middle, and the answer depends on the topper.

If your topper is foam or latex, put the protector over it. Foam cannot be washed, so the protector is the only thing keeping it clean, and a protector over both covers the topper and the mattress at once. This is the order most guides recommend, and for foam it is right.

If your topper is a washable wool layer, put the protector under it. The order is mattress, protector, wool topper, fitted sheet. A waterproof protector on top would sit between you and the wool and stop it doing its job, because the moisture you give off would meet the membrane before it ever reached the wool. Underneath, the protector still keeps the mattress clean and dry for your warranty, and the wool layer stays next to you, where it can work. The topper takes the everyday sweat and wear, and it goes in the washing machine.

New Zealand Wool Mattress Topper on a mattress, held on by wide elastic straps at each corner

An underlay follows the same logic as a wool topper: protector underneath, underlay above it, fitted sheet on top.

Can a topper protect your mattress?

From wear and everyday moisture, yes. A topper sits between you and the mattress, so it takes the nightly sweat, oils and wear first, and a washable one can be cleaned when the mattress cannot. That keeps the mattress cleaner and helps it last. Our wool topper is made to do exactly that, and it machine washes on a cold wool cycle.

From spills and accidents, no. Liquid goes through wool and foam toppers. If your warranty or trial needs a protector, or there are children in the bed, use a waterproof one underneath the wool layer. The two do different jobs and work well together.

How do you wash each layer?

Protectors are the easy one. Most go in the washing machine every few weeks with your sheets, but check the label on waterproof ones, because high heat in the dryer can damage the membrane.

Foam and latex toppers cannot go in the machine. Spot clean them and air them, and rely on a protector over the top to keep them clean.

Wool toppers vary, so check the label, because many are dry clean or spot clean only. Ours machine washes in a front loader, or a top loader with no agitator, on a cold wool cycle with wool detergent. Dry it naturally and let it dry fully before it goes back on the bed. Between washes, a few hours of airing on a dry day freshens it.

Wool underlays are usually heavier and many are spot clean or dry clean only. Air them often and follow the label.

The layer most beds are missing

Most people buy a protector because the mattress shop told them to, and a topper only if the bed feels wrong. The layer they skip is the one that deals with the most common complaint of all, a bed that runs warm and clammy. If that is you, and you like how your mattress feels, the answer is not a thicker topper or a fleece underlay. It is a thin layer of wool, with a protector underneath it. We explain why mattresses run hot in why is my mattress so hot at night.

The New Zealand Wool Mattress Topper from Do Not Disturb Sleep Company is 350gsm of New Zealand wool quilted into a 300 thread count cotton cover, less than a centimetre thick, made by hand in our Auckland workroom. Wide elastic straps at each corner hold it flat under your fitted sheet. It comes in eight sizes, from single to emperor, or made to your measurements for campervans and boats (see our guide to vehicle and boat beds), and it comes with our 30-night guarantee.

A thank you for reading

Take 20% off your order with code BLOG20 at checkout.

Apply BLOG20 and shop the New Zealand Wool Mattress Topper

Can't be combined with other offers. Excludes MiteGuard products.

FAQ

Is a mattress topper the same as a mattress protector? No. A protector keeps the mattress clean and, if waterproof, dry. A topper changes the bed you lie on, either making it softer or, in the case of a thin wool layer, handling heat and moisture at the surface. Some shops use the names loosely, so check what the product actually does.

Do I need a mattress protector if I have a topper? Usually, yes. A topper takes everyday wear but does not stop spills, and almost all mattress brands require a protector during their free trial. If your topper is wool, put the protector under it so the wool stays next to you.

Which goes on first, a mattress protector or a topper? It depends on the topper. With a foam or latex topper, put the protector over it, because foam cannot be washed. With a washable wool topper, put the protector underneath: mattress, protector, wool topper, fitted sheet.

What is the difference between a wool underlay and a wool topper? An underlay usually has a deep fleecy pile, is often reversible and is sold for winter warmth. A wool topper like ours is a thin quilted layer that adds little warmth or softness and is there to keep the surface of the bed dry.

Will my fitted sheet still fit over a topper? Over a thin topper, yes. Ours is less than a centimetre thick, so the sheet you already use should still fit. Thick foam toppers and deep underlays can add enough height to need deeper fitted sheets.

Sources

EL

Ethan Larcombe
Writes for Do Not Disturb, an Auckland sleep company making wool bedding, sleep essentials and home pieces.