Journal/Sleep mist

science

Do Pillow Sprays Work? What the Research Says, and How to Make One Work for You

A pillow spray will not knock you out. Here is what the research on lavender actually shows, why liking the scent matters, and how to give one a fair try.

By Ethan Larcombe| | 8 min read

Sleep Mist lavender pillow spray on a bedside table while a woman settles to sleep in a sleep mask

A pillow spray will not knock you out. A scent you like, used the same way every night, can help you wind down and settle, and lavender has more research behind it than any other scent for sleep. Whether one works for you comes down to three things: what is in it, whether you like it, and how you use it.

Most of what you read about pillow sprays is written by the people selling them, us included. So here is what the research actually shows, where it is thin, and how to give a pillow spray a fair test.

What does the research on lavender and sleep show?

Lavender is the most studied scent for sleep by a wide margin. A 2021 review pooled 34 studies of inhaled aromatherapy for sleep problems and found it helped, with lavender showing the largest effect of the single oils. Most of the single-oil studies in that review used lavender, so it is fairer to call lavender the best tested than the proven best.

A 2024 review of studies in older adults found aromatherapy improved sleep quality, and lavender on its own showed a larger effect than aromatherapy overall.

Two things are worth knowing before you take that at face value. Most of the people in these studies were patients: in hospital, recovering from surgery, or living with an illness. And in most of the trials, people knew whether they were smelling lavender or not, which makes it hard to separate the scent from the expectation.

The most careful trial makes the point. Researchers gave 35 women with insomnia either lavender oil or sunflower oil to inhale at night for 29 nights, without telling anyone which was which. Both groups also got advice on sleep habits and a weekly check-in. Both groups slept better, and there was no clear difference between them on overall sleep quality. The researchers put most of the improvement down to the routine and the follow-up.

That is not bad news for a pillow spray. It is the most useful finding in this article. The routine around going to bed did a lot of the work, and a pillow spray is one way of building a routine.

Is lavender in a capsule the same as lavender on your pillow?

No. Some of the strongest lavender research uses a capsule of lavender oil that you swallow. In one well-known trial, 221 adults with anxiety took a lavender oil capsule or a placebo every day for ten weeks, and the lavender group improved more on anxiety and sleep scores.

That tells you about a measured dose going through your gut and liver. It tells you very little about a light mist on a pillow, which you breathe in for a few minutes as you settle. When a pillow spray points to clinical studies on lavender, check which kind of study it means.

For more on lavender itself, see our guide, Can Lavender Help You Sleep?

Does it matter whether you like the smell?

More than most people expect. In a small study from Japan, researchers split volunteers into people who liked the smell of jasmine tea and people who did not. At a low strength, the scent shifted both groups toward their body's resting state. At a high strength, it did that for the people who liked it, and the opposite for the people who did not: their bodies moved toward alert.

It was only eight people, so treat it as an illustration rather than a rule. But it matches what people say in reviews. The pillow sprays that draw complaints are the ones that smell too strong, too medicinal, or simply not to that person's taste.

Two practical lessons follow. Choose a scent you actually like, not the one you think you should like. And use less rather than more. A pillow spray that fades as you settle is doing its job. One that was still strong at three in the morning would be too strong to sleep against.

It also answers a common question: why does lavender give some people a headache? Strong scents can, and a scent you dislike at full strength is working against you rather than for you.

Why can a pillow spray help you wind down?

The honest answer is less about chemistry and more about learning. Smell has an unusually direct line to the parts of the brain that handle memory and emotion, and the brain is good at linking a smell to a moment.

Researchers have shown this in the classroom. In one study, schoolchildren did better on later tasks when a smell that had been in the room during an earlier success was there again. The smell had become a cue.

It does not always take. In four experiments with about 100 adults, researchers paired sounds with smells and mostly failed to find any learned response in the body. A cue needs repetition, and it needs to mean something to you.

That is the case for using a pillow spray the same way every night. Same scent, same point in the evening, last thing before the light goes off. Over a few weeks it becomes part of how your body knows that bed is coming, alongside dimming the lights and putting your phone down. The Sleep Foundation describes a consistent pre-sleep routine as a core part of good sleep hygiene.

Two more findings help. Once you are asleep, smell barely registers. In a sleep lab study, people noticed scents while drifting off but barely responded to them once they were properly asleep, which is why a bedroom scent will not wake you. And in a study of 34 adults, smells presented during deep sleep, lavender among them, were followed by more of the slow brain waves of deep sleep, without disturbing it. That was a single night with a lab machine rather than a pillow spray, so it is a promising finding rather than a promise.

Our Sleep Mist is built around this idea. It is a light lavender pillow spray, made to be used the same way every night. If you also wear a sleep mask, darkness and scent arriving together make the cue stronger, which is why our Weighted Eye Mask has dried lavender through the fill.

How should you read claims like "97% slept better"?

Sleep spray adverts often lead with big numbers. Before you trust one, ask three questions.

  • Who was asked? Often it is a group of customers or testers who were sent the product, and many of them already like the brand.
  • Compared with what? Many of these figures compare using the spray with using nothing at all. Almost anything you do on purpose before bed beats doing nothing.
  • Did they know what they were using? If people know they are trying a sleep spray, they expect to sleep better, and expectation is powerful.

A fair test would compare the spray with an identical spray that has no scent, without people knowing which one they had. Very few products have been tested that way, which is why we do not put a percentage on ours.

How do you give a pillow spray a fair try?

  1. Shake it if the label says to. Sprays without a solubiliser separate, and an unshaken bottle sprays weaker. Our guide How to Use a Pillow Spray covers the details.
  2. Two or three sprays across your pillow and the top of your bedding, from about 20 to 30cm.
  3. Let it dry before you lie down.
  4. Use it at the same point every night, as part of the same routine.
  5. Give it a few weeks before you decide.

That last step is why the Sleep Mist from Do Not Disturb Sleep Company comes with 30 nights to try it. It is blended and bottled by hand in our Auckland workroom, with true lavender grown spray-free in Canterbury. If it is not right for you after a month, send it back.

A thank you for reading

Take 20% off your order with code BLOG20 at checkout.

Apply BLOG20 and shop the Sleep Mist

Can't be combined with other offers. Excludes MiteGuard products.

FAQ

Are pillow sprays worth it? If you like the scent and use it as part of a routine, a pillow spray is a small, pleasant way to mark the end of the day and help you wind down. If you are hoping it will knock you out, it will not.

How long does a pillow spray take to work? You will notice the scent straight away. The routine part takes longer, so give it a few weeks of using it the same way every night before you judge it.

Why does lavender make you sleepy? Lavender is not a sedative. Its scent is calming for most people, and because so many of us meet it at bedtime, it is also a smell the brain already links with winding down.

Can a pillow spray help with insomnia? A pillow spray is not a treatment for insomnia. It can be part of a good bedtime routine, but if poor sleep goes on for weeks, talk to your doctor.

What is the best scent for sleep? Lavender has the most research behind it. Beyond that, the best scent for sleep is one you like, used lightly.

Sources

EL

Ethan Larcombe
Writes for Do Not Disturb, an Auckland sleep company making wool bedding, sleep essentials and home pieces.