The best sleep mask for a side sleeper is thin and flat at the sides, has no buckles or Velcro, and holds on with two soft straps rather than one tight one. Light is better than heavy, because weight slides when you turn your head. A contoured mask with eye cups is only the better choice if you wear eyelash extensions.
That is the short version. The longer one starts with what actually goes wrong.
Why do sleep masks fail side sleepers?
We read 221 low-star reviews and complaint threads about sleep masks, from retailers, review sites and forums in Australia, the UK and the US, and sorted every complaint by what caused it. Side sleeping came up 35 times. Almost all of it came down to four things.
- Cups and padding that dig in. This was the biggest cause, 16 of the 35. Contoured and padded masks hold the fabric off your eyes with foam cups or thick rims, and when your head is on the pillow, the side of the mask is pushed into your cheek. One reviewer put it simply: “when I laid on my side they dug into my face.” Another said wearing one “feels like trying to sleep with VR gear on.”
- Hardware at the temple. Buckles, sliders and Velcro tabs usually sit at the side of the head, which is exactly where your head meets the pillow. “The buckle of the adjustable strap sits right at the side of my head,” one buyer wrote.
- Pressure on the ear. A single strap has to run somewhere, and on a side sleeper it is often across the ear that is pressed into the pillow.
- The mask shifting as you lie down. Turning your head drags the mask across the pillow. One strap lets it twist; a heavy mask slides.
The shape of the mask made a large difference. In the comments we read, side sleeping made up 29% of the complaints about contoured masks, and 2% of the complaints about flat ones. A few buyers had given up on contoured masks altogether: “I will stick with the flat ones.”
A fair caution: this was a sample of complaints, chosen because they were complaints, so these numbers rank the problems against each other. They are not a measure of how many people are unhappy with each kind of mask. Plenty of side sleepers get on fine with a contoured mask.
Flat or contoured: which is better for side sleeping?
For most side sleepers, flat. It is the honest trade between two good designs.
A contoured mask uses shaped cups to hold the fabric away from your eyes. That keeps it off your lashes and lets you blink freely, and it can seal well around the eyes when you are on your back. The same cups are what press into your face when you roll onto your side.
A flat mask lies close to your face with nothing hard at the edges, so there is nothing to dig in when your cheek is on the pillow. The trade is that it rests lightly on your eyelids and lashes rather than sitting off them. If it feels like it is pressing on your eyes, that is almost always tension, not shape: loosen the straps until the mask only just stays on.
That is why the mask we make is flat. Our Linen & Wisewool™ Sleep Mask is 25 grams and 21.5 by 9cm, with no foam cups and nothing rigid at the sides, because that is what side sleeping needs.
The exception is lash extensions. A flat mask rests on your lashes. If you have extensions, a contoured mask with deep eye cups is the better choice.
Why do two straps beat one?
Most masks have a single elastic band. To stay on, it has to be tight, and a tight band is behind one of the biggest groups of complaints: masks that dig in, leave marks or give people a sore head. “Those that are not adjustable are always too tight,” one reviewer wrote.
Two straps share the job. One sits above the ears and one below, at the back of the neck, so neither has to be tight and the mask cannot pivot when you turn your head. One buyer in our sample asked for exactly this: “it would be more comfortable and secure if there were two straps instead.”

The other thing to look for is what is not there. Buckles, sliders and Velcro all have to sit somewhere, and on a side sleeper that is usually against the pillow. Velcro also catches hair. A strap you knot to length has nothing hard in it, and the knot sits at the back of your head where you never lie on it.
Elastic wears out, too. Stretched or broken straps were one of the more common complaints in our sample. A mask whose strap can be re-tied, or replaced, lasts a lot longer than one where the elastic is sewn in. If yours already slips, see why your sleep mask keeps falling off.
Is a heavier mask better for side sleepers?
No. Weight is lovely on your back: it settles a mask against your face and blocks more light. On your side, the same weight works against you, because when you turn your head, the mask keeps going.
We make a weighted eye mask too, and one of its reviewers said it better than we could. “It is just far too heavy and when you move your head the mask wants to slip to the side.” And: “If you are someone who sleeps only on your back (and doesn’t get the “you’re snoring” elbow when you do) then maybe it would be ok for you however for anyone who moves about - try the other mask.”
So the rule is simple. If you sleep on your back and want the darkest result, a weighted mask is a good choice. If you sleep on your side or move around, go light. Our guide to weighted eye masks versus sleep masks covers the difference in more detail.
What fabric should be against your face?
A side sleeper’s mask spends the night pressed between your face and a pillow, so the fabric matters more than it does for a back sleeper.
- Polyester satin is what most cheap masks are made of. In our sample, nearly all the complaints about stiff, scratchy or noisy fabric, and most of the complaints about chemical smells, were about polyester and foam. “It’s like putting cardboard on your eyes,” one buyer wrote.
- Silk feels smooth and luxurious. It is also delicate: most of the complaints we found about masks being ruined in the wash were about silk.
- Cotton is soft, breathable and easy to wash.
- Linen feels cool when it first touches your skin, breathes well and is strong enough to wash. New linen can be stiff, which is why stonewashed linen matters: it is softened before it is ever made into anything.
Our mask is stonewashed linen on the outside, including the side against your face, with an organic cotton lining and a core of New Zealand wool. The wool never touches your skin. Whatever you choose, check that you can wash it, because a mask that sits on your face every night needs washing far more often than most people do it. Our guide to how to wash a sleep mask covers every fabric.
What if you sleep during the day?
Night shift workers sleep on their sides too, and they need a mask more than anyone. The Sleep Health Foundation’s guidelines for shift workers advise sleeping somewhere that is dark: “block out as much light as possible (e.g., use appropriate window furnishings, wear an eye mask).” The same guidelines suggest a comfortably cool room, blocking noise where you can, and keeping a similar sleep schedule for each type of shift.
For day sleep, a mask that stays put matters even more, because daylight gets in the moment it shifts. Two straps and no weight are the answer here as well.
How should a sleep mask fit when you sleep on your side?
- Fit it lying down. A mask that feels fine sitting up can be loose or tight once your head is on the pillow. Lie on your side and check it there.
- Put the knots or fastenings at the back. Slide them round to the back of your head, never the side.
- Sit the lower strap under your ear lobe, not across your ear.
- Loosen it until it only just stays on. Snug, not tight. If you can feel it pressing on your eyes, it is too tight.
Your pillow matters too. A side sleeper needs a pillow tall enough to keep the neck level, and a mask will never feel comfortable on a pillow that has gone flat. We cover that in the best pillow for side sleepers.
If you want a mask built around all of the above, ours is the Linen & Wisewool™ Sleep Mask from Do Not Disturb Sleep Company: flat, 25 grams, stonewashed linen, two straps you knot to your own head, no buckles or Velcro, and you can hand wash it. It is unscented, so if you like a scent at bedtime, mist the linen lightly with our Sleep Mist and let it dry before you put it on.
A thank you for reading
Take 20% off your order with code BLOG20 at checkout.
Apply BLOG20 and shop the Linen & Wisewool™ Sleep Mask
Can't be combined with other offers. Excludes MiteGuard products.
FAQ
Do sleep masks work for side sleepers? Yes, if the mask suits side sleeping. The problems side sleepers have are mostly caused by bulky eye cups, buckles at the temple and single tight straps, not by wearing a mask at all. A flat mask with two soft straps avoids all three. For whether masks help sleep in general, see does blocking light improve sleep quality.
Are contoured sleep masks better for side sleepers? Usually not. The eye cups that keep a contoured mask off your eyes are what press into your face on the pillow. They are the better choice if you wear lash extensions, and some side sleepers do get on with them.
How do I stop my sleep mask hurting my ears? Move the strap off your ear. On a two-strap mask, the upper strap goes above your ears and the lower one under your ear lobes, at the back of your neck. On a single-strap mask, try wearing the band higher, above the ears.
Can I sleep on my side in a weighted eye mask? You can, but it tends to slide when you turn your head. Weighted masks suit back sleepers best. If you move around in the night, a light mask with two straps will stay put better.
What sleep mask is best for eyelash extensions? A contoured mask with deep eye cups, so nothing touches your lashes. A flat mask rests on them.
Is it OK to wear a sleep mask every night? For most people, yes. The NHS suggests an eye mask as one way to keep your bedroom dark. Keep it snug rather than tight and wash it regularly. If a mask leaves marks or your eyes feel irritated, loosen it, and see your doctor if the irritation carries on.
Sources
- Sleep Health Foundation (Australia). Healthy sleep practices for shift workers. January 2026.
- NHS 111 Wales. Insomnia.
- Do Not Disturb. Our reading of 221 low-star sleep mask reviews and complaint threads from Walmart, Nordstrom, Amazon Australia, ProductReview.com.au, Mumsnet, Trustpilot and online forums, October 2026. A sample of complaints, not a survey of all buyers.